Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
By Spiro Verras
Attorney

The 2016 rule discussed when this article was first published sought to prohibit predispute arbitration agreements in participating nursing facilities. A federal court blocked enforcement of the 2016 prohibition in November 2016. A later federal rule, effective September 16, 2019, removed that prohibition and established safeguards for voluntary agreements. Under the current rules, signing cannot be required for admission or continued care, and the agreement must allow cancellation within 30 calendar days after signing. Explanation, understanding, a neutral arbitrator, and a convenient venue are among the other requirements. See the 2019 final rule and 42 C.F.R. section 483.70(m).

Choosing a nursing home involves decisions about care as well as the admission paperwork. Understanding an arbitration agreement gives your family one less uncertainty to carry into that decision.

You have a choice

A nursing facility participating in Medicare or Medicaid may offer an agreement for binding arbitration, subject to federal requirements. Signing cannot be a condition of admission or continued care. The facility must explain your right to decline, and the agreement itself must state that signing is optional for those purposes.

Arbitration places the covered dispute before a private decision-maker. Before agreeing, understand which disputes the document covers, who has authority to sign, the selection of the arbitrator, and the practical effect on your options.

Protections in the federal rules

The agreement must be explained in a form and language the resident or representative understands, with an acknowledgment of understanding. It must provide for a mutually agreed neutral arbitrator and a convenient venue. It must also expressly allow the resident or representative to rescind within 30 calendar days after signing.

An arbitration agreement cannot prohibit or discourage communication with government officials or the long-term care ombudsman. These protections allow families to ask questions and make a considered choice.

How the rule has developed

The earlier version of this article discussed a rule announced in 2016. The current federal framework permits qualifying arbitration agreements and protects the resident’s choice about signing. A family’s decision should follow the current rules and the actual agreement.

Read 42 C.F.R. section 483.70(m) and CMS guidance on nursing facility arbitration agreements for the governing requirements.

About the Author
For Spiro Verras, good planning begins with understanding the people it is meant to serve. His practice focuses on estate planning, trusts, and probate. A graduate of Yale University and Tulane Law School, he has practiced law since 1993 and founded Verras Law in 2003. He is admitted to practice in Florida, Louisiana, New York, and Texas. You can explore Spiro's National Business Institute Lectures for attorneys and paralegals here.